We advocate

because we care.

At Stephen Benjamin Insurance, our commitment to excellence goes beyond coverage. We believe in empowering individuals and businesses to achieve success and make an impact.


Our Vision

Since 1939, we have helped local families and businesses protect their financial future by matching them with the most effective policies to match their coverage needs.

Our Vision

Our founder, Stephen E. Benjamin, began Stephen Benjamin Insurance in 1939. Benjamin’s daughter,  Betty and and her husband, Robert ran the business out of their home, until they moved it to it's current location in 1978. Their son, Stephen and his wife Joy championed the agency into its third generation of service-minded operations.


Our agency has achieved long-lasting success over the years because of our dedication to exceptional service. We survived the after effects of the great depression. In spite of this adversity, we’ve adapted — and will continue to adapt — in order to best serve you. Stephen Benjamin Insurance listens to our clients’ concerns, answers all questions, and provides sound advice and appropriate, top-rated insurance products that span the test of time.


SBIA is now in the hands of a fourth generation, Steve’s daughter, Lauren LeClaire. And, after 85 years, we are still providing Central Massachusetts and the Blackstone Valley with the very best property and casualty insurance.


We hope you will look to our local insurance agency to protect your financial future. We have a vested interest in keeping you - our valued clients, neighbors and friends - safe and secure because your future is our future.

A man and woman are posing for a picture in front of a window.
A man and a woman are standing next to each other in a black and white photo.
A man and a woman are posing for a picture together
A woman with long brown hair is smiling and wearing a green shirt.

Based in Sutton, Massachusetts

Phone: (508) 865-9534

Fax: (508) 865-4439

497 Central Turnpike
Sutton, MA 01590


Monday – Friday: 8:00am to 4:00pm 

Staff may be available outside of regular business hours by appointment.