Pay Your Bill
Pay Via PartnersAt Stephen Benjamin Insurance Agency, our associates are here to provide you with superior assistance Monday-Friday, 8am - 4pm. If you need assistance with how to pay your bill, to pay your bill in person, or if you have questions regarding your policy please feel free to visit us at our office at 497 Central Turnpike in Sutton or contact us via phone (508-865-9534) or email.
If you’re looking to take care of payments after business hours or if you have additional questions, please follow the contact information below for our partners.
Filing a Claim
Always contact Stephen Benjamin Insurance Agency directly if a loss occurs.
Monday - Friday, 8am - 4pm
Fax: (508) 865-4439
497 Central Turnpike,
Sutton, MA 01590
If you have had a loss and need assistance after our normal business hours, you may contact your company directly (24 hours) at the following numbers:
Arbella:
1-800-ARBELLA (1-800-272-3552)
The Norfolk and Dedham Group:
M - F 8 a.m. to 4 p.m.
After 4 and weekends/holidays:
Request a Certificate
Request CertificatePlease note that requests are not binding until you receive confirmation from a representative of SBIA.
Request a certificate by completing the form at the link below.
Request a Policy Change
Request Policy ChangePlease note that requests are not effective nor binding until you receive confirmation from a representative of SBIA. Some requests may require further action or discussion. If you have any questions please feel free to call us at (508) 865-9534.
Request a change to your policy by completing the form at the link below.
Referrals
Send a Referral Now!The greatest compliment we can receive is for our current clients to refer their family and friends to our agency and recomend our customer service focused approach to insurance.
Trust and dependability are earned in the insurance industry by building long-lasting relationships with our clients to assist with their insurance needs over time as their lives change. We hope that through that trust and dependability, you’ll want to send your family, friends, and neighbors to get their insurance locally so they may experience the same level of service you have come to know over the years.
When you refer your family or friends to have a policy review done by our agency, we pay it forward and it’s a win-win-win! With our client referral program you…
- Support a local, independent, family owned and operated insurance agency that has been in Sutton since 1939!
- The folks that you refer to us have the opportunity to purchase insurance customized to suit their needs backed by top-notch companies.
- You help support Whittier Farms, a local family owned and operated farm in Sutton since 1945 that is now in their 5th generation! How? Because we are going to give you a $15 gift card to their farm store as our way of saying thank you.
How to send us a referral:
Make sure the person who is contacting us provides us with your name, email address or cell phone number. If you want to send us names of people for us to contact, please complete the referral form below. When you provide names and contact information, we will copy you on the emails that we send so that they are aware that you have sent us their contact information.
When you help your friends, family, and neighbors with their insurance, you support not 1, but 2 local businesses! We appreciate your continued business with our agency and your support by shopping small.
*Rules and program are subject to change at any time at the discretion of Stephen Benjamin Insurance Agency. We reserve the right to change or discontinue this referral program at any time without notice.
Eligibility: For the purposes of this Program, a Referral may only come from a current client. A Referral is a qualified prospect – that is, a person who will give us all the necessary information to create a proposal on their behalf.
Let’s find the right coverage for you.
Whether you're protecting your home, car, or business, we’re here to help. Contact us today for a personalized quote and experience the trusted service that has kept our clients covered for over 85 years.
Serving our community for over 85 years.
© 2025
All Rights Reserved | Stephen Benjamin Insurance | Privacy Policy